13a. Comparing Governments
The Statue of Liberty is a symbol of freedom and democracy for people around the world.
No two governments, past or present, are exactly the same.
However, it is possible to examine the similarities and differences among political and economic systems and categorize different forms of government. One simple way to categorize governments is to divide them into democratic and authoritarian political systems.
Many countries today claim to be democracies, but if the citizens are not involved in government and politics, they are democratic in name only. Some governments are more democratic than others, but systems cannot be considered truly democratic unless the meet certain criteria:
Whither democracy? It was not until 1920 — after decades of tireless protest and campaigning — that women were granted suffrage by the ratification of the 19th Amendment.
- Freedom of speech, the press, and religion. Democracies in general respect these basic individual liberties. No government allows absolute freedom, but democracies do not heavily censor newspapers and public expression of opinions.
- Majority rule with minority rights. In democracies, people usually accept decisions made by the majority of voters in a free election. However, democracies try to avoid the "tyranny of the majority" by providing ways for minorities all kinds to have their voices heard as well.
- Varied personal backgrounds of political leaders. Democracies usually leave room for many different types of citizens to compete for leadership positions. In other words, presidents and legislators do not all come from a few elite families, the same part of the country, or the same social class.
- Free, competitive elections. The presence of elections alone is not enough to call a country a democracy. The elections must be fair and competitive, and the government or political leaders cannot control the results. Voters must have real choices among candidates who run for public office.
- Rule by law. Democracies are not controlled by the whims of a leader, but they are governed by laws that apply to leaders and citizens equally.
- Meaningful political participation by citizens. By itself, a citizen's right to vote is not a good measure of democracy. The government must respond in some way to citizen demands. If they vote, the candidate they choose must actually take office. If they contact government in other ways — writing, protesting, phoning — officials must respond.
The degree to which a government fulfills these criteria is the degree to which it can be considered democratic. Examples of such governments include Great Britain, France, Japan, and the United States.
Mao Zedong's position as authoritarian ruler of the People's Republic of China is glorified in this propaganda poster from the Cultural Revolution. The poster reads: "The light of Mao Zedong Thought illuminates the path of the Great Cultural Revolution of the Proletariat."
One ruler or a small group of leaders have the real power in authoritarian political systems. Authoritarian governments may hold elections and they may have contact with their citizens, but citizens do not have any voice in how they are ruled. Their leaders do not give their subjects free choice. Instead, they decide what the people can or cannot have. Citizens, then, are subjects who must obey, and not participants in government decisions. Kings, military leaders, emperors, a small group of aristocrats, dictators, and even presidents or prime ministers may rule authoritarian governments. The leader's title does not automatically indicate a particular type of government.
Authoritarian systems do not allow freedoms of speech, press, and religion, and they do not follow majority rule nor protect minority rights. Their leaders often come from one small group, such as top military officials, or from a small group of aristocratic families. Examples of such regimes include China, Myanmar, Cuba, and Iran.
No nation falls entirely into either category. It also dangerous to categorize a nation simply by the moment in time during which they were examined. The Russia of 1992 was very different from the Russia of 1990. Both democratic and authoritarian governments change over time, rendering the global mosaic uncertain and complex.
This remarkable website, painstakingly compiled by an enthusiast, lists the heads of state and heads of government for almost every nation, territory, and autonomous area you can think of, from as far as back as the 1800s. The website also includes an impressive chronology of recent events (mostly related to world leaders), a list of foreign ministers by country, as well as information on the membership and leadership of major international organizations.
Report broken link
Get to know the Prime Minister of India on this beautifully arranged website, and learn what it takes to run the most populous democracy in the world. Take a look at his speeches, tour his office, and even read his poetry at this comprehensive site. Some features require RealAudio.
Report broken link
Who was recently spotted wearing the number 2000 for the New York Mets? Prime Minister Yoshiro Mori of Japan, that's who. Find the Prime Minister's profile, learn about the cabinet, and peruse other information about the Japanese government at the Prime Minister's official website.
Constitution and Government of Japan
Jump here to find out the nitty-gritty of how Japan is governed. Read the Japanese constitution, or examine the various organizational charts to understand the structure of the government.
Report broken link
What's more democratic than free elections? Nothing, especially for the International Foundation for Election Systems, a nonprofit organization that provides assistance and research so voters throughout the world can enjoy the democratic process. Browse through pages of international election data and find out things like voter turnouts and election results.
Report broken link
Many of us take our freedoms of speech, press, and religion for granted. The International Freedom of Expression Exchange doesn't. This nonprofit organization keeps an eye out for violations and victories throughout the world in its campaign against censorship. Check their latest alerts to see which authoritarian regimes (and which democracies) are limiting the rights of their citizens.
Report broken link
The Xinhua News Agency — the official state news agency of the People's Republic of China — is often viewed as an extension of the government rather than as an independent press organization. See how their news follows (or diverges from) the Communist party line.
Report broken link
The Sultan of Brunei is a busy man: not only is he the richest person in the world, but he also actively governs his nation as Prime Minister, Defense Minister, Finance Minister, and head of the Islamic religion in Brunei. Read about the royal family, the constitution of Brunei, and the country itself on this attractive official website.
Report broken link
No, not the Jenny Craig of Japan — the Japanese Diet is Japan's equivalent of the House of Representatives. The English language version of its website has information on everything from the strength of Japanese political parties to its Research Commission on the Constitution. Don't miss the diagram of legislative procedure (located in the Guide to the House) to see how Japanese bills become law on this well-organized, easily navigated website.
Report broken link
If you like our content, please share it on social media!
Gully cricket is popular amongst young boys in India. They just troop into a street with little traffic outside their homes and start hitting the ball with the bat. Now, there are a number of ways in which this can be organized.
When only one boy brings a bat, he rules. He keeps batting even when he gets out and he lets his close friends also bat or as long as they want. If he wants to end the game, he simply walks away with the bat. Let’s call this the Bossy Bully system.
Sometimes all the cricket equipment – bat, ball, stump, gloves, etc is contributed by all. So each boy gets a good batting chance, a chance to wear the pads and gloves. Let’s call this the Just Friends system.
Sometimes there is a coach. In that case, the coach monitors and improves the game of each and every boy in his tutelage. But you don’t get to say whether you like the way he coaches. This can be the Big Brother system.
If we think of these teams as forms of government and of course you have to imagine that there are extremely many boys playing in the street, then the ‘bossy bully’ is a dictatorship; ‘just friends’ is a socialist government and or could even be a democracy depending on how you look at it; a ‘big brother’ is totalitarian and if one of the players owns the street where the boys are playing, it would be a monarchy.
There are 7 Types of Government
Modern governments are complex and are shaped by historical and political events like wars and colonialism. A democracy is governed of the people, by the people and for the people. Here citizens of the country can run for public office. This means the boys in the street get to decide who is in charge of what equipment is in the pile. Of course, each boy will nominate the person who best represents his interests.
Democratic elections could be city-wide for municipal governance, state-wide for state governance or nation-wide for central governance. When the population goes to vote, they vote for a candidate in their area. When the candidate wins, the political party he belongs to also wins. The party with maximum votes forms the government.
What happens here? People enjoy freedom.
In contrast, a dictatorship where a single individual has gained power through force and everyone has to follow his policies. He’s the big bully. The boys have little to no voice in such a system. Oftentimes the advisors who control the equipment kit are his close friends. Examples of dictators are Adolf Hitler in Germany and Fidel Castro of Cuba.
Sometimes you have what is known as a ‘benevolent dictatorship.’ This is when the dictator maintains his position as the head of the country for the sake of the country instead of self interest. Most dictatorships like to portray themselves in the international community as benevolent but it is not always so.
What happens here? Many people are unhappy in this system.
A monarchy is another form of government where there is one head of state. In this system a king or queen rules the country for as long as they are alive. The crown is inherited, usually by the first born of the family.
In earlier days, monarchs used to have absolute powers and owned all the public land. Pharaohs for example, claimed to be representatives of the Gods on earth. But nowadays, even democracies like Great Britain, Sweden, and Spain have kings who are nominal heads of state. Still it is their signature that turns a bill into a law.
What happens here? Things work well if the king is a good sportsman and cares about street cricket by choosing the right boys to be prefect of the equipment kit.
In countries where any religious institution holds power over the king, the form of government is called a theocracy. Several Islamic nations fall into this category.
What happens here? It’s like saying everyone must eat cucumber sandwiches for lunch every day.
There are totalitarian governments where a single group of friends have had control of the pile of equipment for decades. It is like dictatorship by a party instead of an individual. The regime maintains complete control of the country by not allowing any other people to form a political party.
They control all aspects of a citizen’s public and private life through art, science, and educational propaganda. The former Soviet Union and Vietnam are examples of totalitarian governments.
What happens here? It’s like having the same class prefect term after term.
Some nations are republics, such as the USA. It is a democratic model – people are elected to government office by voters. It is however, headed by a single individual whose office is also elected by the people – the President.
What happens here? This is nicer – everyone gets to be prefect for a while.
And finally, a country that is usually in the throes of a war or civil unrest and no functioning government is said to be in a state of anarchy.
What happens here? This is somewhat like the snack at someone’s place after a particularly gruelling game of street cricket– mum has a tough time cleaning up afterwards.
Ask your teacher to divide you into teams. The size of each team will depend on how many people are in the class, of course. Each team must pick a form of government and get to rule for the day. Discuss what happens in the classroom during the rule of each government. Is the room cleaner? Is the blackboard / whiteboard kept ready for the teacher’s use? Is there less bullying? Which rule is more fun for ALL?